Friday, March 25, 2011

Miss Dialectic & Miss Anti-Dialectic (Can they Just Get Along)

Dear Colleagues on Both Sides of the Desk
           
              Miss Dialectic
The heart of the heart of  Liberal Art
  (not to be confused with liberal arts,
   majors & minors--prerequisites and
   capstones & stuff like that. ).
 
 
Some Aspects of ARGUMENT-ability

 
1. Got to love it as much as rugby and old
time music: argument for it’s own sake—
not to win/lose but, like hacky sack to keep
it in play
 
2. Got to love the “enemy”—worthy opponent,
other-side, team, across the I’ll: antithesis,
antagonist: turn it up, bring it on.
 
3. Got to see thru the tokens, no getting stuck
in content, subject-object matter, double binds,
Gordian Naughts, Tar Babies or Chinese Finger
Traps --nor in “logic” or consistency, controlling
metaphors: meta-force savvy & able to push them
overthe edge where they all break down or switch
in mid-stream, snuffling-up hidden and obvious
assumptions: :watching the talk, not (just) content.
 
4. Sensitive to transgressions: border crossing
frontiers yet unknown
--my own, others; dialectic
can't begin  till someone gets ”hurt” so to speak:
offence, insult--ouch, oh-my, damnit--right there
is  where the game starts—not in scoring, but in
considering the nature of the injury: what’s being
protected that was trans-parent &  unacknowledged?
 
5.  Edification  Dialectic embracing debate and
dialogue: in order to be building up awareness of
the topic and the process: a shared "shining."
 
6.  Always an ongoing Environmental Issue. Creating
an atmosphere  where the practice is seen as profitable
a process as “useful”  as taking notes and examination. 
Grade-gun demands & issues fully understood and not
with standing. .

        

               Miss Anti-Dialectic
 (The heart of liberal arts: majors and minors,
pre-requs and capstones: not to be conflated
with Liberal Art)

xxxooo, Sam (Please: improve my terms. They
always need it.  We could argue. )

No comments:

Post a Comment